Playing Ep 01

What people are saying

• gentlechoe

  Overall 8

  Story 8,  Acting 8.5,  Music 8,  Rewatch Value 7.5

  In a realm of illustrious fantasy where destiny intertwines with the threads of love and sorrow, the screen adaptation of a poignant and shadow-laced literary work set within the realms of Novoland unfolds. This heart-wrenching narrative weaves the lives of three central figures – a loyal protector, a tormented sovereign, and a defiant seafarer – into a tapestry resonating with themes of remorse, unyielding longing, and the perennial battle against the inexorable forces of destiny.
  
  Though the storyline and character interpretation visibly diverge from the original...

  pages, the adaptation preserves the literary spirit that we cannot simply bend fate to our will. The series may not cast as somber a reflection as the written words from which it was born, yet it is suffused with an anguish and complexity that will not resonate with every viewer. The tale is notably underscored by a deeply intense and co-dependent bond between the sovereign and his unwavering protector – an interlacing so profound that freedom is rendered a mere illusion. The female seafarer, whose fate seems sealed from the outset, battles against an unyielding current as she vies for affection, only to find herself adrift in the turbulent waters of a love unreachable.
  
  Initially, the series languishes under the weight of delayed character progression, which is compounded by reliance on a flashback technique that occasionally stumbles on-screen. Despite expecting more from seasoned performers, one must acknowledge the palpable chemistry that later develops, which propels the series into compelling territory. While certain character portrayals may not fully capture the intricate layers intended by the source material, other depictions outshine the written counterparts with commendable depth, particularly the strikingly tenacious female seafarer. However, a mismatch in voice portrayal subtly mars the character's believability within the forbidden context of her affections.
  
  Amidst the complexity of the narrative lies a minor player who acts as a pivot, steering the story into an unexpected arc. Regrettably, her development takes a detrimental turn as the narrative progresses. Supporting relationships, though a soothing contrast to the surrounding malaise, lack the emotional grip that could have enriched the tale further.
  
  This cinematic vision does not skimp on splendor – its lavish accouterments and well-orchestrated action sequences are commendable, yet it is ultimately a saga of characters more so than events, with some subplots and antagonistic arcs not achieving their full potential. The storyline's zenith might arguably be an event preceding the final chapter, where the notion of lovers' reunification reveals itself most poignantly. As the tale nears its conclusion, there is a discernible faltering – an anticlimactic end borne from too-rapid resolutions and underestimated adversaries.
  
  In its last breath, the series offers an affecting resolution for a pair of star-crossed lovers – a swan song performed with heartrending finesse. Still, one cannot overlook the series' departure from the novel's darkly enchanting inevitability. The resulting sentiment is one of untapped potential – a tale that, while etched by fate, seems to have lost its way. Grading the series is a task that waveringly oscillates between moderate and favorable marks, though the number who may find merit closer to distinction will likely be those who let the penultimate chapter stand as the final echo of the journey.

• sunnylin52

  Overall 7.5

  Story 7.5,  Acting 7.5,  Music 8,  Rewatch Value 7.5

  This review may contain spoilers
  The series in question held such promise, given its lavishly produced historical backdrop populated with renowned actors, and yet, to the chagrin of many, it falls short of the mark in entwining its multiple genres into a coherent and gripping narrative. It takes a fair number of episodes to fully grasp the story, with the performances and rapport amongst the leads feeling somewhat disengaged.
  
  Performance-wise, comparisons inevitably arise with actors of different series set in the same era, where others may...

  have delivered more nuanced and emotionally resonant portrayals. One lead actor's gaze, often described as lifeless, only gains significant depth during the drama’s concluding segments. Another, known for her consistency in roles, delivers a performance that's adequate but never quite extraordinary. A newcomer to historical fiction overshoots initially, coming off stronger than needed, but thankfully finds equilibrium as the story unfolds. The supporting cast delivers serviceably but without eliciting standout accolades.
  
  When it comes to romance, the weaving of various love threads had the potential to be the drama's emotional cornerstone, but instead, it leaves viewers somewhat detached. One central pair's relationship, built amidst a fortress of secrets, fails to engage the audience in their plight for a shared future. Another romantic trajectory begins with troubling power dynamics and despite an intriguing start, takes an unsettling turn when grievances are too readily dismissed, diminishing the female character's earlier portrayed strength.
  
  A tertiary, yet refreshingly genuine romantic subplot shines despite its simplicity, yet it, unfortunately, is left dangling with inadequate resolution, a narrative misstep that deprives the audience of closure. A more successful dynamic is the intricate bromance which proved to be the series's emotional core, showcasing a layered and poignant friendship that often outshadows the romantic elements.
  
  In the arena of court intrigue, the climactic reveal feels like a missed opportunity, and the actions of a certain military figure challenge the audience’s suspension of disbelief due to a jarring lack of logical character development.
  
  From a production standpoint, the series visibly benefits from a sizable budget, boasting exquisite costumes, intricate set designs, and a tasteful use of CGI, particularly in its portrayal of mythological creatures. The soundtrack is pleasant, if not particularly memorable, and thankfully not overutilized to manipulate viewers' emotions.
  
  While it finds itself within the Novoland universe, those yearning for action-packed scenes may find the offerings too few and far between. Additionally, the series’s voice dubbing becomes a point of contention among fans, with some performances marred by mismatched vocal portrayals.
  
  Ultimately, while the aspirations of grandeur are evident in the scale and design of the series, the execution falters, leaving an impression of an epic that could have been but never quite was.

• grumpycinderella67

  Overall 9

  Story 9,  Acting 9,  Music 10,  Rewatch Value 8.5

  An exquisite production that effortlessly kindles a yearning for more! The landscapes depicted in this drama are a feast for the eyes, the Jifeng Pavillion, with its intricate woodwork and soft white petals cascading like winter flakes, is a sight to behold. The meticulous attention to costumes, thrilling choreography, and the seamless CGI will undoubtedly captivate the audience's attention—a testament to the superb quality of production that can also be admired in works helmed by the illustrious Lin Yu Fen, reminiscent of other ethereal series,...

  albeit with a slightly more somber and terrestrial tone. Fear not, newcomers to the Novoland universe, this story stands proudly on its own, with no requisite of prior viewing to become wholly immersed.
  
  Our tale commences with the complex master-disciple dynamic of Fang Jianming and Fang Haishi, blossoming into a painfully sweet forbidden love affair. It's an intricate dance of destiny and restraint, defying simplicity in favor of a tortuously slow-burning passion that only makes moments of tenderness all the more precious. In this series, the allure truly lies in the maturity of its storytelling and the profound evolution of the characters. Brace yourself; you're in for a wildly emotional rollercoaster ride.
  
  Yang Mi shines, slipping into the role of a formidable, cross-dressing protagonist with ease. Her youthful vibrancy is at once both playful and shrewdly daring—a natural fit that benefits greatly from her authentic vocal performance, lending credibility to her portrayal. The action sequences are particularly spellbinding, as her character exudes a fierce aura during intense combat scenes that demand undivided attention. As Ms. Pearl emerges, we witness the transition from her youthful exuberance to an aura of sophistication, neatly delineating her character's progression through life. Her comedic repartee with Zhouying is a delight, their sibling rivalry laced with humor and undeniable affection, showcasing the layers of their deep fraternal bond.
  
  Initially, William Chan's portrayal of Fang Jianming may require an adjustment period, his initial appearance seemingly understated. Yet, patience bears fruit as his performance unfolds with a composed, yet fierce demeanor—a protective nature hiding behind an icy exterior. His character displays an unsettling level of devotion to the Emperor, teetering on the brink of self-sacrifice, which adds a curious dimension to the narrative, evoking comparisons with other renowned stoic figures. The Baixi oath, tying his fate to Emperor Xu, introduces a not-so-average twist in the complex web of relationships that defy conventional expectation.
  
  The ensemble also introduces other romantic pairings, each weaving their own thread within the grand tapestry of intertwining destinies, yet maintaining their individual narrative beats. Emperor Xu, while a figure of frustration at times, later reveals layers of complexity in his passionate interaction with Jianming, amid the clash of their complicated camaraderie. Meanwhile, the gentle Tilan provides a stark contrast to Haishi, representing the restrictions of royal lineage and gender expectations.
  
  One cannot help but crave more from Zhuoying and Zheliu, whose relationship exudes an adorable innocence that offers a refreshing counterweight to the series' more intense moments. Their relationship is a testament to the varied spectrum of love portrayed within the series.
  
  Acoustically, the series enchants with a lineup of stellar performers, gracing the opening and closing credits with their voices. Zhang Bichen and Zhou Shen bring an air of magnificence that resonates harmoniously with the narrative, their melodic interpretations as moving as they are poetic.
  
  All in all, the show dazzles with its cinematographic prowess and a storyline ripe with unforeseen developments. For those who relish a historical drama that dares to tug on the heartstrings, this series is a crown jewel eagerly awaiting your viewership.
  
  Memorable utterances that resonate deeply include Fang Haishi's poignant acknowledgment of the precarious line between life and death and her fear of being pushed away by her master far more than the fear of death itself. Fang Jianming expresses a desire for Haishi to avoid his painful path and instead find happiness—a wish voiced amidst his own personal turmoil. The wrought bond between Jianming and Emperor Xu is laid bare in their own words, speaking of unyielding loyalty and a desire for the other's unbridled happiness—exchanging the roles of ruler and protector, friend and confidant.
  
  Such vulnerability and strength coalesce in this drama, inviting viewers to not only witness but feel the heart of its narrative pulse with profound emotion.

• boldben

  Overall 9.5

  Story 9.5,  Acting 9,  Music 9.5,  Rewatch Value 9

  Loyalty, Love & Heroism
  
  In the grand tapestry of narratives that weave together friendship, romance, and the heroics of selfless characters, this particular series stands out as a poignant tale. Adapted from a beloved novel which I have yet to delve into, the TV interpretation reportedly renders some of its characters in a more sympathetic light, possibly to endear them further to the audience. The result is a top-tier production graced with stellar performers and a storyline that enchants with its beauty.
  
  Recently, dramas exploring the delicate...

  relationship between mentor and protégé have seen a surge in popularity—a trend this series rides with a nuanced take. Confronting the complexities of propriety in such dynamics, the show artfully sidesteps judgment, allowing its audience to ponder the intricacies on their own.
  
  The story introduces us to a young girl rescued and subsequently adopted by a skilled and enigmatic warrior. Disguised as a male for her safety and renamed, the protagonist is schooled in the gamut from scholarship to martial prowess. Seeds of admiration for her "shifu" blossom into a forbidden love, only complicated by his deep allegiance to the Emperor—a relationship grounded in near-sacrificial fealty. This intricate dance of love and loyalty is the pulsating heart of the series.
  
  The casting deserves particular applause, particularly the transition of the young heroine from an innocent, determined youth to a formidable yet feminine figure. While her portrayal is mostly compelling, some nuances feel less convincing, sparking debate among viewers about the authenticity of her on-screen presence.
  
  Performances by the male leads add depth and gravitas, with the powerful portrayal of a disciple-turned-spy earning commendation for his compelling dual roles. Meanwhile, the depiction of the Emperor wavers, though the enduring bond with his loyal servant touches the heart.
  
  Among the praise, the series isn't shielded from criticism, notably concerning the less robust villains who, unlike their literary counterparts, face swift demises. Yet, the adaptation’s handling of the protagonists' fates is skillfully done, altering controversial plot points from the novel to better align with modern sensibilities—a decision sure to please the romantics.
  
  What truly resonates is how the narrative tucks away underexplored subplots, particularly regarding the secondary but by no means lesser character arcs. Their tales hold a potential richness that could reward the viewer if expanded.
  
  The production also boasts elements of fantasy, including eloquent sea creatures and dark magical arts, all beautifully rendered through impressive CGI. Interestingly, this installment of a larger franchise stands alone, not requiring past entries for comprehension, and thrills with its kinetic wuxia sequences and striking visual storytelling.
  
  Despite initial tepid responses from viewers, as reflected in its preliminary ratings, the series has climbed out of the depths to reach a more stable appreciation post-release. Discourse around the female lead's performance and her co-star's contribution remains divided, but I implore audiences to look beyond such controversies. The series, with all its imperfect pieces, is stitched together into a compelling and visually stunning narrative quilt.
  
  In sum, this show is a journey worth embarking upon. Rich in character, lush in production value, and ambitious in scope, it deserves the chance to captivate. It receives my eager recommendation—an emphatic endorsement for those drawn to the grandeur of emotional and adventure-rich storytelling.

• HappyYoon96

  Overall 5.5

  Story 7,  Acting 6,  Music 5,  Rewatch Value 1

  A Promising Kickoff Marred by Sluggish Progression and Lackluster Acting
  
  As an aficionado of Yang Mi's oeuvre, it pains me to confess that my anticipation for her latest venture went largely unfulfilled. The initial episodes, teeming with bow-wielding and battlefield prowess, showcased her finest moments. Alas, the romantic narrative, steeped in yearning, seemed to unfold solely within her character's psyche, taking far too long to materialize onscreen. The performances proved to be adequate, yet they lacked the luster we've come to expect from such esteemed talents.
  
  William...

  Chan's initially distracting hairstyle, fluctuating between a traditional bun and a lengthier, side-swept look, might catch the eye for the wrong reasons. Despite his undeniable appeal, these hairstyle choices occasionally detracted from his onscreen allure. As for the score, it failed to leave a lasting imprint on the memory – passable, yet ultimately forgettable.
  
  One may argue the series has garnered excessive acclaim; a possible testament to a year scarcely sprinkled with high-caliber historical extravaganzas. It stands to reason that forthcoming productions of greater finesse will eclipsing this one, leading audiences to retrospectively view it as overpraised. However, I recognize the current tide of leniency on which its reputation sails.
  
  The subplot involving the secondary couple, particularly the Emperor's arc, outshines the main plot. There lies the crux of captivating storytelling – an intricate tapestry of personal evolution and unwavering intensity. This character alone marks a highlight amidst a sea of mediocrity.
  
  In conclusion, the series barely steadies itself on the tightrope of watchability. As a seasoned consumer of countless dramas, perhaps my judgment is clouded by a waning tolerance for the indulgent pace of yesteryear. Yet, even through an objective lens, the drama fails to soar beyond average heights. It’s peppered with both triumphs and deficiencies, but its lack of resonance makes it a transient affair in the vast drama landscape. A hearty drama should linger in one's mind well beyond its final curtain – anything less earns a tepid shrug. If your watchlist is threadbare, this may serve as a time-filler. But I advise tempering your expectations – this is no magnum opus.